Special

Get 20% OFF now on your first purchase! Use code: JOIN20

Get 20% OFF! Use code: JOIN20

Start Now

Static vs Trailing Drawdown: The Numbers That Decide It

The same headline percentage means very different things depending on whether your drawdown trails. Here is a day-by-day account showing exactly where the two diverge.

Categories:

Tags:

Share:

Two firms both advertise a 10% maximum drawdown. One is static, one trails. These are not variations of the same rule — they are different products, and the difference is worth more than most of the pricing you are comparing.

This guide works through a single account day by day under both, so you can see precisely where they diverge.

The Two Definitions

Static drawdown sets a fixed floor from your starting balance and leaves it there. On a $100,000 account with 10% max drawdown, your floor is $90,000 on day one and $90,000 six months later, whatever happens in between.

Trailing drawdown attaches the floor to your high-water mark and drags it upward as you profit. Reach $109,000 and your floor becomes $99,000. It moves up. It does not move back down.

That last sentence is the whole article. Everything below is the arithmetic.

The Same Account, Both Ways

A $100,000 account with a 10% maximum drawdown. Five trading days.

Day P&L Balance High-water Static floor Trailing floor Static room Trailing room
Start $100,000 $100,000 $90,000 $90,000 $10,000 $10,000
1 +$3,000 $103,000 $103,000 $90,000 $93,000 $13,000 $10,000
2 +$4,000 $107,000 $107,000 $90,000 $97,000 $17,000 $10,000
3 +$2,000 $109,000 $109,000 $90,000 $99,000 $19,000 $10,000
4 −$5,000 $104,000 $109,000 $90,000 $99,000 $14,000 $5,000
5 −$6,000 $98,000 $109,000 $90,000 $99,000 $8,000 Breached

Read day five carefully

The trader is at $98,000. They are down $2,000 from where they started. On a $100,000 account that is a 2% loss.

Under static drawdown they have $8,000 of room left and a perfectly ordinary week behind them.

Under trailing drawdown the account is dead.

Nothing exceptional happened. There was no blow-up, no oversized position, no rule broken in spirit. The trader made money, gave some back, and finished slightly down. Trailing drawdown converted a normal drawdown into a terminal one, because the floor followed the profits up and then refused to follow them back down.

Notice the third column from the right

Under static, the room grows as you profit — $10,000 to $19,000 across three good days. Under trailing it is pinned at $10,000 no matter how well you trade. You never earn breathing space. You are permanently three bad days from the floor, whether you are up $500 or up $50,000.

The Second Question: Balance or Equity?

Once you know the drawdown trails, ask what it trails from.

Balance-based trailing updates the high-water mark only when a position closes. Your floor moves when you bank profit.

Equity-based trailing updates on unrealised profit too. Open a position, watch it run $4,000 in your favour, and your floor rises by $4,000 — immediately, before you have taken a penny.

The consequence is sharp. Let a winner retrace and you have moved your own floor up against yourself using money you never received. Traders who let positions breathe, or who scale out gradually, breach on equity-based trailing far more often than their results justify.

Same headline percentage. Materially different rule.

The Third Question: Intraday or End of Day?

Intraday evaluates the floor continuously. A spike against you at 3am on thin liquidity can breach the account before you are awake.

End-of-day evaluates once, at the daily close. Intraday noise does not count; only where you finish does.

End-of-day is substantially more forgiving, particularly for swing traders and anyone holding through sessions. It is also less common, and worth paying for when you find it.

Which Suits Which Trader

If you Prefer Because
Hold positions for days Static, or EOD trailing Intraday equity swings will not close you out
Scalp intraday, flat by close Trailing is workable You bank frequently; the floor moves in small steps
Scale out of winners Static, or balance-based Equity trailing raises the floor on profit you have not taken
Trade few, large positions Static Trailing gives no room for the variance your style creates
Are on your first evaluation Static One less mechanism to misjudge while you learn the rest

The Four Questions

Every drawdown rule reduces to these. Get all four answered before you buy, from the rulebook rather than the pricing page.

  1. Static or trailing?
  2. If trailing: balance-based or equity-based?
  3. Evaluated intraday or end of day?
  4. Does it change between the evaluation and the funded account?

That fourth one catches people. A permissive static drawdown during the evaluation and a tight trailing one once funded is a legal, disclosed and extremely common combination — and it means the account you practised on is not the account you end up trading.

FOREXIVE publishes both rulebooks in full at help.forexive.com, before purchase. Ask the same four questions of us and of everyone else on your list.

Related Reading

Drawdown is one of the two rules that decides outcomes; the other is the consistency rule, which has arithmetic just as unforgiving. Our seven-question evaluation framework covers what else to check, and our 1-Step, 2-Step and Instant accounts set out our own sizes and pricing.

FAQs

What is a trailing drawdown?
A maximum loss limit whose floor follows your highest account value upward. Reach a new high and the floor rises with it. It does not fall back when your balance does.

What is a static drawdown?
A fixed floor set from your starting balance that never moves. On a $100,000 account with 10% maximum drawdown, the floor stays at $90,000 permanently.

Which is better?
Static is more forgiving in essentially every scenario, and the room it gives you grows as you profit. Trailing is workable if you trade intraday and bank frequently. If you hold positions or scale out, static is worth paying more for.

Can I breach a trailing drawdown while still profitable overall?
Yes, and it is common. In the example above the trader breaches while down only 2% from their starting balance. Reach a high-water mark, retrace, and the floor is waiting where your profits used to be.

What does equity-based trailing mean?
The high-water mark updates on unrealised profit, so an open position moving in your favour raises your floor before you close it. Let that winner retrace and you have moved the floor up against yourself with money you never banked.

Does the drawdown rule change after I get funded?
At many firms, yes — typically tightening. Ask for the funded-account rulebook before buying the evaluation, not after passing it.

Trading involves substantial risk of loss. Evaluation and funded accounts described here are simulated trading environments. Figures in this article are illustrative. Nothing on this page is financial advice, and no outcome is guaranteed.

Related Posts

Reviews

{{ reviewsTotal }}{{ options.labels.singularReviewCountLabel }}
{{ reviewsTotal }}{{ options.labels.pluralReviewCountLabel }}
{{ options.labels.newReviewButton }}
{{ userData.canReview.message }}

Create your account